American Idol

[Crash]

I'm pretty sure Fantascia and Diana will be in the final. That'll be a guddun.

[Star]

I actually felt a bit sorry for Jasmine - did you hear that booing?? :shock:

[David]

Originally posted by Star
I actually felt a bit sorry for Jasmine - did you hear that booing?? :shock:
Well exactly, poor girl simply does NOT deserve that!

[lolly]

Originally posted by Star
I actually felt a bit sorry for Jasmine - did you hear that booing?? :shock:


I'm watching it now. 'Everlasting Love' was really very bad.

'Love you inside and out' is much better.

[Star]

Originally posted by lolly
I'm watching it now. 'Everlasting Love' was really very bad.

'Love you inside and out' is much better.

I actually didn't see the performances! I just got home in time to see the results - I'll have to catch up on Sunday!

[lolly]

Not overly keen on Fantasia's 'Knock On Wood' either.

[David]

Ranking the performances for me:

1. Diana - No More Tears
2. Latoya - Don't Leave Me This Way
3. Diana - This Is It
4. Latoya - Love You Inside And Out
5. Fantasia - Knock On Wood
6. Fantasia - Holding Out For A Hero
7. Jasmine - Everlasting Love
8. Jasmine - It's Raining Men

[Crash]

Originally posted by lolly
Not overly keen on Fantasia's 'Knock On Wood' either.

yeah me 2 but i DID enjoy her version of the Bonnie Tyler song, even tho the judges werent particularly keen!

[David]

Fantasia's performance of 'Knock On Would' was Vegas cabaret, there wasn't much wrong with her vocal on 'Holding Out For A Hero', but it was a WOEFUL song choice!

[lolly]

Does Donna actually perform? I can convince Steve to stay up and watch it if she does...

[David]

Originally posted by lolly
Does Donna actually perform? I can convince Steve to stay up and watch it if she does...
She does 'Last Dance' on the Results show, after the contestants do a medley of her songs!

[Crash]

For Me:

1. Diana - No More Tears
2. Fantasia - Holding On For A Hero
3. Diana - This Is It
4. Latoya - Love You Inside And Out
5. Fantasia - Knock On Wood
6. Latoya - Don't Leave Me This Way
7. Jasmine - It's Raining Men
8. Jasmine - Everlasting Love[/B][/QUOTE]

[David]

How anyone can have Latoya's rendition of 'Don't Leave Me This Way' ranked sixth is beyond me!

[Crash]

Originally posted by David
How anyone can have Latoya's rendition of 'Don't Leave Me This Way' ranked sixth is beyond me!

i caught the tail end of it, i was out getting drinks at the time, so i missed it, so i put it there, but just because it was Latoya i put it in front of Jasmine ;)

[lolly]

I haven't been keeping up with this thread from the beginning. Who has been people's favourites all the way through? David, I'm guessing you know Jester's and VoR's...

[David]

Jester was pro Jon Peter Lewis and Diana DeGarmo, VoR was pro Jennifer Hudson and now Jasmine Trias, my favourite started out as Fantasia, then Latoya, and now torn between Diana and Fantasia...

[jester]

Donna sang 'MacArthur Park' on the results show. Did they cut that out?

[lolly]

Why am I not surprised by VoR liking Jasmine?

[Toyah]

Originally posted by jester1436
Donna sang 'MacArthur Park' on the results show. Did they cut that out?

No, they showed it here. She was in FINE voice, hasn't half piled on the weight though!

[lolly]

Originally posted by Toyah
No, they showed it here. She was in FINE voice, hasn't half piled on the weight though!

The hair needs attention too!

[Crash]

Every was LOCKED in discussion in my house about whether her hair was a wig or not? We actually never came to a conclusion

[lolly]

1. Latoya - Don't Leave Me This Way
2. Diana - No More Tears
3. Diana - This Is It
4. Latoya - Love You Inside And Out
5. Fantasia - Knock On Wood
6. Fantasia - Holding Out For A Hero
7. Jasmine - Everlasting Love
8. Jasmine - It's Raining Men



Very similar to David's!

[lolly]

Originally posted by Crash
Every was LOCKED in discussion in my house about whether her hair was a wig or not? We actually never came to a conclusion


You'd think she could have bought a GOOD one!

[Star]

Totally OT, but I has a patient at work the other day who had a really crap wig on and I dislodged it when I put his glasses on him.

[lolly]

Originally posted by Star
Totally OT, but I has a patient at work the other day who had a really crap wig on and I dislodged it when I put his glasses on him.

Was he horribly embarrassed?

[Crash]

Originally posted by lolly
You'd think she could have bought a GOOD one!

it was rather all over the place wasnt it?

[lolly]

I am actually inclined to think it was her own hair...

[Toyah]

She should have a word with her pal Diana Ross. Now THERE'S a woman who knows how to wear a wig!

[Star]

Originally posted by lolly
Was he horribly embarrassed?

I think I was more embarassed than him! :shock: I just kept apologising while my work mates were doubling up with laughter in the background!

[David]

Originally posted by jester1436
Donna sang 'MacArthur Park' on the results show. Did they cut that out?
I didn't watch the whole show!

[Crash]

Originally posted by lolly
I am actually inclined to think it was her own hair...

dear LORD if it was

[lolly]

Diana was great in 'Bad Girls', Latoya less so on 'Hot Stuff'.

[lolly]

Jasmine and Fantasia both failed to impress in the medley.

[David]

About a month ago I said that Diana could NOT win this competition, but after Glo week and this week, she could even be the favourite!

[lolly]

Donna is in FINE voice though!

[lolly]

Is Donna still without a record deal on both sides of the Atlantic?

[Crash]

Originally posted by David
About a month ago I said that Diana could NOT win this competition, but after Glo week and this week, she could even be the favourite!

Ive always liked Diana! Her personality really shines and she seems like a really sweet girl, and she has some voice on her. It WILL be between Fantasia and Diana

[Crash]

Originally posted by lolly
Is Donna still without a record deal on both sides of the Atlantic?

i do believe so! shame....:(

[jester]

Originally posted by lolly
Is Donna still without a record deal on both sides of the Atlantic?

Yup!

Apparently her true desire is to release a country album of all things...

[David]

Originally posted by Crash
Ive always liked Diana! Her personality really shines and she seems like a really sweet girl, and she has some voice on her. It WILL be between Fantasia and Diana
I still don't think she's mastered the art of being gracious in victory... There are still things I don't like about her, but I think Quentin Tarantino did her a HUGE favour by telling her that she was 'So what?'