The high notes in "A New Argentina" are meant to be piercing, it's a political rally speech, so Madonna fails at the gate on that one. Whoever made the video above should have compared like with like. The Patti LuPone section was a lipsync job from the Tonys, whereas the other stage Evitas are singing live.
I have an incredibly soft spot for the grit and determination of Buenos Aires, the vulnerability that the judges have been looking for of Another Suitcase, and of course the all the drama of the death-era songs (You Must Love Me, Don't Cry for Me Reprise, Lament).
I rarely ever listen to it. I like most of her vocals to be honest and I think she elevated her performance and expanded her technical range whilst retaining her emotional resonance and not descending into musical theatre parody. I don't give a rat's ass if Patti LuNONE hated it and they had to change keys or whatever. Fuck her & the high Broadway horse she rode on.