I was...
so disappointed by this
I was SO excited about seeing it, but it really was bottom-drawer Almodovar for me to the point where I'm unsure if I'd actually watch it again.
As others have noted, the two plot-lines didn't really MESH together particularly well, and as a result both sides felt rather underwritten to me.
The melodrama aspect was extremely sober and muted for Almodovar - not a bad thing, just a bit different - but also had the issue where every single twist and turn I saw coming a mile away. It just felt a bit uninspired, and I found how it all rapidly and neatly wrapped up similarly disappointing - I was hoping for a Cruz spiral into MADNESS in the final third, but instead the film veered away completely and focused on the other storyline.
I really wish he'd either made a
melodrama, and really gone ALL OUT with it - like I said, Cruz spiralling and a proper climax to the story could have been fantastic! Or alternatively, I wish he'd gone all out and made a Spanish historical drama, focusing on the graves, the villagers and telling the story via flashbacks etc.
As it stands neither aspect of the film worked brilliantly for me. The main story was FINE, and I was happy watching it (I would NEVER not enjoy dipping into his world and characters) but it felt a tad underwritten both plot and character-wise.
It's worth saying also that I'm SUCH an Almodovar fanboy that I'm always going to be unnecessarily critical of his work, and this film certainly wasn't BAD in any way.
Cruz was incredible, possibly a career-best performance, and Milena Smit was full of potential as the blue-eyed, full-lipped support. I wish the film had found more time to explore her relationship with her parents.
Fabulous of course to see so many cameos (Daniela Santiago!), especially Rossy getting one of her more extended of cameo appearances
Again her character showed potential, but was underwritten (where were the one-liners?)
I don't even know where I'd rank it in his canon. Dark Habits is the only other of his films I don't like much, and I'd still absolutely rewatch that any time given the chance