What's your Melanie C top 10?

Jark

User
Joined
Oct 27, 2007
Messages
50,742
I do realise this may be pushing it for some of you despite the recent goodwill... :eyes: I'm sure @VoR will be happy to contrbute though.

01 Enemy
02 I Turn To You (album edit)
03 Think About It
04 Blame It On Me
05 Never Be the Same Again
06 Last Night on Earth
07 Stupid Game
08 Beautiful Intentions / Next Best Superstar
09 On the Horizon
10 Anymore / Overload

don't all rush at once :disco: @Pipo sis I'm very curious for yours
 
1. I Turn To You (Hex Hector Mix)
2. Goin’ Down
3. Never Be the Same Again
4. Anymore
5. Think About It (7th Heaven Mix)
6. GaGa

that’s about as far as I can go without clutching - but I do like those 6 a lot. I also like her new stuff but need to let that settle.
 
I want to, but I guess it’s going to be all from the first 2 albums, I only had the first 3 and I don’t remember Beautiful Intentions at all

she has some good B-sides
 
1. Feel the sun
2. Closer
3. Melt
4. Think about it
5. Never be the same again
6. Gaga
7. I turn to you (Hex Hector)
8. Northern star
9. In and out of love
10. Goin' down/Let's love
 
Ooh @Jark YES at the Enemy love! :disco:

Let's see:

01 Who I Am
02 Think About It
03 Northern Star
04 Enemy
04 I Turn To You (single mix)
05 Carolyna
06 Here I Am
07 Never Be The Same Again
08 Blame It On Me
09 In And Out of Love
10 Anymore
 
Gaga
I Turn To You
Water
Beautiful Intentions
Next Best Superstar
Understand
One By One
Anymore
Good Enough
Overload
 
Last edited:
I want to, but I guess it’s going to be all from the first 2 albums, I only had the first 3 and I don’t remember Beautiful Intentions at all

she has some good B-sides

In this age of free music could you not even be bothered to give the latest one a whirl?
 
01. Closer
02. Never Be the Same Again
03. I Turn to You
04. Northern Star
05. Feel the Sun
 
In this age of free music could you not even be bothered to give the latest one a whirl?

i never got into streaming, I’m still barely listening to music at all unless I force myself to. I’m not sure why.

I’ve seen some of her new videos on YouTube though, it sounds decent. What’s the one in the art gallery?
 
i never got into streaming, I’m still barely listening to music at all unless I force myself to. I’m not sure why.

one in the art gallery?

Who I am.

All of the singles from this ALBAM have been decent to be fair.
 
01 Northern Star
02 Carolyna
03 I Turn To You
04 Next Best Superstar
05 Who I Am
06 Here It Comes Again
07 If That Were Me
08 Understand
09 Better Alone
10 Think About It
11 Yeh Yeh Yeh
12 In and Out of Love
13 Melt
14 On The Horizon
15 Loving You
16 Never Be The Same Again
 
Last edited:
I'd struggle to put a top 5 together, let alone a top 10.

That being said:

1. Northern Star
2. Never be the Same Again
3. I Turn to You
4. Going Down
5. Ga Ga

And that's a wrap on Mel C.
 
I'd struggle to put a top 5 together, let alone a top 10.

That being said:

1. Northern Star
2. Never be the Same Again
3. I Turn to You
4. Going Down
5. Ga Ga

And that's a wrap on Mel C.
Honestly the new stuff is GOOD
 
You mean the new album or anything post-Northern Star?


I once heard that 'Carolyna' one (which I can see is gracing many of the longer-than-top-5 lists here :eyes: ) and it was a fucking earsore. I literally wanted to die.
 
Never saw the video for Understand before. I think this is one of her best songs but was a little surprised by the “Mel goes cruising on a train” storyline.
 
Your Mistake was the best song on This Time, I don't know why it wasn't released. I was a fan at the time but looking back that whole era was such a bore, she really didn't know where she was going. très MOR.

@Suedey she's had a few really good songs since then - I'd check out Think About It, Anymore, Blame It On Me and Overload if you're at all curious
 
Never saw the video for Understand before. I think this is one of her best songs but was a little surprised by the “Mel goes cruising on a train” storyline.


I totally forgot about the majestic 'Understand' and also remember being totally bemused by the video. I'll have to edit the all important Menly Halli-Top 15 now.
 
You mean the new album or anything post-Northern Star?


I once heard that 'Carolyna' one (which I can see is gracing many of the longer-than-top-5 lists here :eyes: ) and it was a fucking earsore. I literally wanted to die.

I agree. Just give the singles a spin on youtube. Start with Who I Am and In and Out of Love
 
Bar one or two of her most well known songs I am largely unfamiliar with her back catalogue. This is the first album I have listened to.
 
Also her personality is far more tolerable now than it was in her younger days.
 
1. Ga Ga
2. I Turn To You (Single Mix)
3. Never Be The Same Again

fin.
 
the strings! the drums! the vox! the tsunami of emotion!
:disco:
 
1. Never Be The Same Again - albam version
2. I Turn To You - singal mix
3. Goin' Down
4. Northern Star
5. Anymore
6. Think About It
7. Who I Am
8. When You're Gone
9. Loving You
10. Enemy
(11. Blame It On Me
12. Closer
13. Feel The Sun)
 
I mean honestly people have 'Yeh Yeh Yeh' (the 17th worst song of all time) and 'Melt' on their listettes here what can I even say anymore at this point.
 
1. I Turn To You (signal remix)
2. Northern Star
3. Never Gonna Be The Same Again (albam version)
4. Who I Am
5. Ga Ga
6. Going Down
7. Blame It On Me
8. When You're Gone (Bryan Adams FEAT. Mel C)
9. Closer
 
Last edited:

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top Bottom