Madonna - Music

[Funky]

Floella thinks it's better than ROL. Do you?

I would five Madonna albums above it, personally.

But it still has some DEFINING MOMENTS

But then what Madonna album DOESN'T

 

[VoR]

Another ten for me. Maybe a 9.5 if that was allowed. She really was on FIRE at this point in her career. This and ROL are my top two albums of hers for sure.

08 Music
10 Impressive Instant
10 Runaway Lover
10 I Deserve It
07 Amazing
09 Nobody's Perfect
10 Don't Tell Me
08 What It Feels Like For A Girl
10 Paradise (Not For Me)
09 Gone

 

[Funky]

Something always BUGS me about "Music". I do agree she was on fire at this point and could do no wrong... but it's just missing that SOMETHING. Maybe it's because the title track isn't actually one of her best, as iconic as it is. Maybe there's just too much experimental electronica on there. Some of it feels a little unnecessary.

I like the fact that some songs have grown on me more over time though. "Paradise" and "Gone" particularly.

08 Music
09 Impressive Instant
07 Runaway Lover
06 I Deserve It
07 Amazing
05 Nobody's Perfect
10 Don't Tell Me
08 What It Feels Like For A Girl
10 Paradise (Not For Me)
09 Gone

 

[JET BOY]

I have never understood why people love Paradise and dislike Nobody's Perfect, for me they were the 2 instant album standouts for me

Anyway, this is definitely my favourite Madonna album I think, maybe a tie with The First Album, even though as an album it sits horribly together, incredibly disjointed. Oddly enough I don't really like any of the singles, they would probably be my 3 least faves on the album, with perhaps Amazing coming just before Don't Tell Me

 

[Karvel]

One of my favourite albums ever, an absolute masterpiece. And the tracklisting is perfect

10 Music
10 Impressive Instant
10 Runaway Lover
10 I Deserve It
10 Amazing
09 Nobody's Perfect
10 Don't Tell Me
10 What It Feels Like For A Girl
10 Paradise (Not For Me)
08 Gone

 

[Christian]

"What It Feels Like For A Girl" and "Amazing" (UGH) render it inferior to Ray Of Light for me. Plus we'd already heard Paradise by the time it was released which led to a feeling of being somewhat shortchanged.

Having said that, I absolutely love "Nobody's Perfect" (all time Madge Top 10 for me) and the really quite moving "Gone".

 

[Ellie]

Ugh, Nobody's Perfect is my MUST SKIP song.

 

[Christian]

I love it. The vocoder is used perfectly to create that sense of longing and regret. Plus it was amazing in Drowned World.

 

[Ellie]

08 Music
08 Impressive Instant
07 Runaway Lover
10 I Deserve It
08 Amazing
01 Nobody's Perfect
10 Don't Tell Me
06 What It Feels Like For A Girl
10 Paradise (Not For Me)
10 Gone

 

[Sheena]

07 Music
09 Impressive Instant
07 Runaway Lover
07 I Deserve It
03 Amazing
05 Nobody's Perfect
07 Don't Tell Me
09 What It Feels Like For A Girl
10 Paradise (Not For Me)
07 Gone

It's aged badly for me but its high point remains SO good that it pulls the album up overall to an 8...

 

[Annie R.U.O.K.]

Far FAR FAR better than 'Ray of light', this album is probably my favourite of hers as a whole. I even like 'American pie'!

 

[Joseph]

9

Runaway Lover is useless... love the rest

 

[Dandy]

08 Music
09 Impressive Instant
08 Runaway Lover
07 I Deserve It
07 Amazing
07 Nobody's Perfect
10 Don't Tell Me
08 What It Feels Like For A Girl
10 Paradise (Not For Me)
09 Gone

Another 8. I find it easier to listen to than 'Ray Of Light' on the whole but most of the tracks are just good as opposed to exceptional. 'Don't Tell Me' is one of my favourite things she's ever done.

 

[Loufoque]

A real peaks and troughs album for me

10 Music
10 Impressive Instant
03 Runaway Lover
09 I Deserve It
06 Amazing
04 Nobody's Perfect
10 Don't Tell Me
05 What It Feels Like For a Girl
10 Paradise (Not For Me)
10 Gone

 

[Floella]

I have never understood why people love Paradise and dislike Nobody's Perfect, for me they were the 2 instant album standouts for me

Absolutely! I didn't even know "Nobody's Perfect" was so disliked in the Madonna camp. I always play that and "Paradise" together. They're like inseparable brothers.

Well this is my favourite Madonna album ever...although bear in mind I've only heard the last four. Creative and fun without being vapid like "Confessions...", but also some reflective moments without being worthy and pretentious.

08 Music
09 Impressive Instant
06 Runaway Lover
08 I Deserve It
06 Amazing
09 Nobody's Perfect
09 Don't Tell Me (Severe overplay killed its 10 rating)
08 What It Feels Like For A Girl
9.5 Paradise (Not For Me) (Goes on a bit)
07 Gone

= 7.95/10

 

[Jonfessions]

Amazing brings it down to a 9.

 

[Beverley]

I look at a lot of the songs very individually and REALLY LIKE THEM but I find the album as a whole a little COLD.

 

[Loufoque]

To me this was the last album where Madonna really MATTERED

So even though it has some ULTIMATE CRAP on it, I still think of it more fondly than the 3 albums that followed it

 

[Frozen]

8 Music
9 Impressive Instant
9 Runaway Lover
7 I Deserve It
7 Amazing
6 Nobody's Perfect
9 Don't Tell Me
6 What It Feels Like For A Girl
2 Paradise (Not For Me)
7 Gone

 

[Lockhart]

05 Music
10 Impressive Instant
08 Runaway Lover
04 I Deserve It
07 Amazing
08 Nobody's Perfect
02 Don't Tell Me (the radio edit is pleasnt, but the album version is dreadfully long)
-1 What It Feels Like For A Girl (THE worst song EVER created by ANYONE)
10 Paradise (Not For Me)
09 Gone

 

[Jonfessions]

HEATHEN

What It Feels LIke For A Girl is lovely.

 

[Lockhart]

Its impoissible for even me, a complete LOON to love everything she spurts out

 

[Jonfessions]

Oh every LOON has their dislikes, but WIFLFAG (wiffle fag ) is gorgeous.

 

[ameraal]

i see i've given this a 7 back in the day, fair enough

08 Music
07 Impressive Instant
06 Runaway Lover
07 I Deserve It
10 Amazing
10 Nobody's Perfect
07 Don't Tell Me
05 What It Feels Like For A Girl
07 Paradise (Not For Me)
09 Gone

somehow i feel the need to say i'm honestly not fucking around with that rate

 

[Loufoque]

I love the WIFLFAG REMIXES

But I just cannot get on board with the original

I remember my mum liking it back in the day WHICH SAYS IT ALL

 

[ameraal]

it makes me ILL
i have the single though, it had some fine remixes on it for the time

 

[POP!]

Why on earth did I give it a 5? It's easily an 8.

07 Music
10 Impressive Instant
07 Runaway Lover
09 I Deserve It
09 Amazing
08 Nobody's Perfect
09 Don't Tell Me
10 What It Feels Like For A Girl
08 Paradise (Not For Me)
09 Gone

 

[Loufoque]

I've just had a MOMENT with this album

EDIT

10 Music
08 Impressive Instant
07 Runaway Lover
09 I Deserve It
06 Amazing
07 Nobody's Perfect
10 Don't Tell Me
06 What It Feels Like For a Girl
10 Paradise (Not For Me)
10 Gone
09 American Pie

 

[POP!]

I feel like this is her most underplayed album from me, which is odd because it's such an easy listen and is my favorite album of hers from the 2000s.

When you tire of the "Vogue"s and "Holiday"s of her catalog, "What It Feels Like..." and "Don't Tell Me" REALLY hit the spot

 

[ameraal]

i see i've given this a 7 back in the day, fair enough

08 Music
07 Impressive Instant
06 Runaway Lover
07 I Deserve It
10 Amazing
10 Nobody's Perfect
07 Don't Tell Me
05 What It Feels Like For A Girl
07 Paradise (Not For Me)
09 Gone

somehow i feel the need to say i'm honestly not fucking around with that rate

what a hater

 

[Christian]

10 Music
08 Impressive Instant
08 Runaway Lover
07 I Deserve It
03 Amazing
11 Nobody's Perfect
05 Don't Tell Me
04 What It Feels Like For A Girl
10 Paradise (Not For Me)
10 Gone

7 seems a bit low in retrospect. I might bump it up to an 8 these days.

Jark is full on INSANITY mode there though. "Amazing" is DROSS. Of course people care it's a carbon copy of something else - especially when it's something that seems to have been copied TWENTY FIVE TIMES on a TWENTY YEAR OLD machine.

 

[Cécile]

I have nothing but love for this album. *loon rate*

10 Music
11 Impressive Instant
09 Runaway Lover
08 I Deserve It
05 Amazing
09 Nobody's Perfect
10 Don't Tell Me
08 What It Feels Like For A Girl - The Above and Beyond remix is a 73/10
10 Paradise (Not For Me)
09 Gone

08 American Pie
09 Cyber-Raga

 

[ameraal]

09 Music
08 Impressive Instant
07 Runaway Lover
07 I Deserve It
09 Amazing
09 Nobody's Perfect
07 Don't Tell Me
07 What It Feels Like For A Girl
08 Paradise (Not For Me)
10 Gone

more of an 8, i guess, but it still feels like a transitional record, not a defining one

 

[Kevin]

11 Music
10 Impressive Instant
09 Runaway Lover
07 I Deserve It
08 Amazing
08 Nobody's Perfect
09 Don't Tell Me
08 What It Feels Like For A Girl (Above and Beyond Remix 10)
09 Paradise (Not For Me)
10 Gone

10 American Pie

 

[Funky]

08 Music
08 Impressive Instant
07 Runaway Lover
05 I Deserve It
06 Amazing
02 Nobody's Perfect
10 Don't Tell Me
07 What It Feels Like For A Girl
10 Paradise (Not For Me)
09 Gone

PATCHY I don't even acknowledge American Pie, but if I did it would be a BIG FAT ZERO.

 

[Lockhart]

Yes well an in a MUCH needed update to my previous able rate:

07 Music
10 Impressive Instant
08 Runaway Lover
05 I Deserve It
07 Amazing
06 Nobody's Perfect
07 Don't Tell Me
02 What It Feels Like For A Girl
10 Paradise (Not For Me)
08 Gone

06 American Pie
09 Cyber-Raga

It's patchy but both Impressive Instant and Paradise are wondrous and go quite some distance to make up for the rest. I think a 5 is a little harsh now, it's more of a 6 or 7.

 

[VoR]

08 Music
09 Impressive Instant
08 Runaway Lover
09 I Deserve It
07 Amazing
10 Nobody's Perfect
08 Don't Tell Me
06 What It Feels Like For A Girl
10 Paradise (Not For Me)
09 Gone

Brilliant. I love how dark and moody it is in places.

 

[Cerro de Casa]

10 Music
10 Impressive Instant
08 Runaway Lover
09 I Deserve It
05 Amazing
10 Nobody's Perfect
09 Don't Tell Me
11 What It Feels Like For A Girl
11 Paradise (Not For Me)
10 Gone

A bit JARKETTE I know, but it IS my 2nd favourite Madonna album..

 

[Loufoque]

Jark off as much as you want Suede. This is a killer pop album made by a woman at her SECOND PEAK of RELEVANCE.

 

[Christian]

I like American Pie. Yes I DO. Though clearly the best thing from that "era" is "Time Stood Still".

Oh PLEASE dial Pat Leonard's number again, FOR PITY'S SAKE

*speed dials David Guetta and Pharrell *