I think Scarlett is brilliant - her pitch was perfect there. Shame the rest of her team were so dog at advertising. But it won't be decided on anything in this episode.
But... I think Karina might be the winner... there's just something about how she's been edited the last couple of episodes that feels like a winner... I'm not sure.
Same - I think that Karina was probably the right choice overall in terms of the business, but Scarlett was by far the better candidate in terms of presentation and overall strategic thinking on the TV show. If it had been the old style prize of a job with Sugar, I'd have definitely taken Scarlett over Karina.